Paradox of Metal-rich Stars in Early Universe  

Study of image taken by the JWST has led to discovery of a galaxy in the early universe about a billion years after the big bang whose light signature is attributed to its nebular gas outshining its stars. Now named GS-NDG-9422, the galaxy is chemically complex and does not have Population III stars. Similarly, the most distant galaxy JADES-GS-z14-0 formed in the early universe about 290 million years after the Big Bang was found to have metals. As per the current understanding, the first generation of stars of the early universe should be Population III stars with zero metallicity. In astronomy, any element heavier than helium is considered a metal. Chemical non-metals like oxygen, nitrogen etc are metals in cosmological context. Stars get metal enriched in each generation following supernova event.   

Using image captured by NIRSpec (Near-Infrared Spectrograph) instrument of James Webb Space telescope (JWST), researchers have identified a unique galaxy from the early universe at a red shift of Z= 5.943 corresponding to approximately one billion years after the big bang. Now named GS-NDG-9422, this galaxy may be a missing-link phase of galactic evolution between the first stars of the universe and well-established galaxies. 

The faint dot image of the galaxy GS-NDG-9422 has unique light signature. The source of light seen in the image is galaxy’s hot gas. The light did not come from its stars.  

Unlike massive stars in our local universe whose temperature is about 40,000 to 50,000 °C, stars in GS-NDG-9422 galaxy are extremely hot. Perhaps, this galaxy was in star formation stage inside a dense gas nebula producing a large number of massive, hot stars when the light left this galaxy about 12.8 billion years ago to reach the JWST now. The observation fits the computer model that constant bombardment of the nebular gas by the photons of the hot stars heated the nebular gas to more than 80,000 °C enabling it to shine brighter in near-infrared light than the stars.  

A galaxy dominated by nebular light (rather than starlight) is in line with environments of the first generation of stars of the early universe. Stars in such galaxies are Pop. III stars with zero metallicity. However, surprisingly, galaxy GS-NDG-9422 does not have Population III stars. JWST data shows that GS-NDG-9422 is chemically complex.  

The case of the most distant galaxy JADES-GS-z14-0 formed in the early universe about 290 million years after the Big Bang is still more perplexing. Stars in this galaxy should be Pop. III stars with zero metallicity however, study of infrared properties of JADES-GS-z14-0 galaxy reveals presence of oxygen which means metal enrichment implying generations of stars should have already completed their life- cycles.  

The first stars in the universe have zero-metal or extremely low-metal. They are called Pop III stars (or Population III stars). Low metal stars are Pop II stars. Young stars have high metal contents and are called “Pop I stars” or the solar metal stars. With a relatively high 1.4% metallicity, sun is a recent star. In astronomy, any element heavier than helium is considered a metal. Chemical non-metals like oxygen, nitrogen etc are metals in cosmological context. Stars get metal enriched in each generation following supernova event. Increasing metal content in stars indicates younger age. 

*** 

References:  

  1. Cameron A.J., et al 2024. Nebular dominated galaxies: insights into the stellar initial mass function at high redshift. Published: 21 June 2024. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, Volume 534, Issue 1, October 2024, Pages 523–543, DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/mnras/stae1547 
  1. NASA News – In Odd Galaxy, NASA’s Webb Finds Potential Missing Link to First Stars. Avaialble at  https://science.nasa.gov/missions/webb/in-odd-galaxy-nasas-webb-finds-potential-missing-link-to-first-stars/  
  1. Prasad U., 2024. Early Universe: The Most Distant Galaxy “JADES-GS-z14-0″ Challenges Galaxy Formation Models. Scientific European. Published 12 August 2024. Available at http://scientificeuropean.co.uk/sciences/space/early-universe-the-most-distant-galaxy-jades-gs-z14-0-challenges-galaxy-formation-models/ 

***  

Latest

Daraxonrasib Approved for Pancreatic Cancer

Daraxonrasib (Rasonque by Revolution Medicines, Inc.), an inhibitor of...

Glacial Collapse Led to Seismic Event in Nepal 

The magnitude 5.2 seismic event recorded near the border...

Significance of Nancy Grace Roman Space Telescope

Nancy Grace Roman Space Telescope (commonly referred to as...

NASA Invites ISRO to Join Moon Base Programme

NASA has invited ISRO (Indian Space Research Organisation) to...

2026 Total Solar Eclipse

On 12 August 2026, a total solar eclipse was...

AI Designs Complete Functional Genomes

The genome language model Evo 2 has designed novel...

Newsletter

Don't miss

Lunar Race: India’s Chandrayaan 3 achieves Soft-landing capability  

India’s lunar lander Vikram (with rover Pragyan) of Chandrayaan-3...

Cost Effective Way to Convert Plants into Renewable Source of Energy

Scientists have shown a new technology in which bioengineered...

JWST’s Deep Field Observations Contravene Cosmological Principle

James Webb Space Telescope’s deep field observations under JWST...

Non-parthenogenetic animals give “virgin births” following Genetic engineering  

Parthenogenesis is asexual reproduction in which genetic contribution from...

“Pan-coronavirus” vaccines: RNA Polymerase Emerges as a Vaccine Target

Resistance to COVID-19 infection has been observed in health...

Extinct Thylacine (Tasmanian tiger) to be Resurrected   

Ever changing environment leads to extinction of the animals unfit...
Umesh Prasad
Umesh Prasad
Umesh Prasad is a researcher-communicator who excels at synthesizing peer-reviewed primary studies into concise, insightful, and well-sourced public articles. A specialist in knowledge translation, he is driven by a mission to make science inclusive for non-English speaking audiences. Toward this goal, he founded “Scientific European,” this innovative, multilingual, open-access digital platform. By addressing a critical gap in global science dissemination, Prasad acts as a key knowledge curator whose work represents a sophisticated new era of scholarly journalism, bringing the latest research to the doorstep of common people in their native languages.

Daraxonrasib Approved for Pancreatic Cancer

Daraxonrasib (Rasonque by Revolution Medicines, Inc.), an inhibitor of the RAS GTPase family has been approved for the treatment of adults with metastatic pancreatic...

Glacial Collapse Led to Seismic Event in Nepal 

The magnitude 5.2 seismic event recorded near the border between Nepal and China on 26 August 2026 at 8:37 AM local time (02:52:10 UTC) has...

Significance of Nancy Grace Roman Space Telescope

Nancy Grace Roman Space Telescope (commonly referred to as Roman Telescope) is set to be launched into space on 30 August 2026. It will...

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

For security, use of Google's reCAPTCHA service is required which is subject to the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.

I agree to these terms.