Low EROI of Fossil Fuels: Case for Developing Renewable Sources

Study has calculated energy-return-on-investment (EROI) ratios for fossil fuels from first extraction stage till the last stage when the usable fuel is ready. It is concluded that fossil fuels EROI ratios are low, declining and are similar to renewable sources of energy. Development of cost and environment friendly renewable sources is needed to meet our energy demands.

Fossil fuels like oil, coal and gas are dominating the energy production around the globe. Fossil fuels are beleived to provide high energy-return-on-investment (EROI). This is the ratio of how much energy is needed to extract a fossil fuel source like coal or oil and how much usable energy this source will eventually produce. Fossil fuels like oil, gas and coal have high EROI ratio of 1:30 meaning one barrel of oil extracted can produce 30 barrels of usable energy. Since the EROI ratio of fossil fuels are usually measured during the extraction process from ground (the primary stage), ratios calculated so far fail to take into account the energy which is required to convert these ‘crude’ or ‘raw’ forms into usable fuels like petrol, diesel or electric power.

On the other hand, renewable sources of energy like wind and solar have been estimated to have EROI ratios below 10:1 which is far lower mainly because they require initial infrastructure like windmills, solar panels etc which comes at a considerable cost. However, fossil fuels are limited in supply as one day our planet will run out of them. Fossil fuels also heavily pollute the environment. Alternative renewable sources of energy are urgently needed.

A study published on July 11 in Nature Energy has investigated the global energy-return-on-investment of fossil fuels over a total duration of 16 years at the primary stage (extraction) and at the last finished stage. While EROI ratios at primary stage were approximately 30:1 and agreeable with previous calculations, researchers found that EROI ratios at the finished stage are 6:1. This number is also consistently decreasing and is similar to renewable sources of energy.

Low EROI

The cost of extracting fossil fuels is rapidly increasing which could soon deplete the ‘net energy’ for finished usable fuels because of the additional energy required to process raw fossil fuels. Also, fossil fuels arn’t easily accessible anymore thus requiring higher energies to be extracted thereby excalating the energy cost.

The current study shows that EROI ratios of fossil fuels are now becoming closer to renewable sources of energy. Renewable sources of energy require initial infrastructure like windmills, solar panels etc and thus are not considered as having good EROI. However, fossil fuel EROI ratios have declined by almost 23 percent in 16 years, therefore, it becomes imperative to remove our dependency on fossil fuels and opt for more renewable sources of energy considering cost and environmental factors.

***

{You may read the original research paper by clicking the DOI link given below in the list of cited source(s)}

Source(s)

Brockway, P. et al. 2019. Estimation of global final stage energy-return-on-investment for fossil fuels with comparison to renewable energy sources. Nature Energy. http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/s41560-019-0425-z

Latest

Meteor Produces Daytime Bolide and Sonic Boom Across New England  

A loud sonic boom was heard and a fireball seen around 18:06 UTC Saturday 30...

Carbon-free Ferrocene Analog Synthesised

The synthesis of the first carbon-free inorganic sandwich compound  (an osmium...

Outbreak of Bundibugyo Ebolavirus in DR Congo and Uganda

The current orthoebolavirus outbreak in Democratic Republic of Congo...

Neanderthals Performed Dental Caries Interventions 59,000 Years Ago

Prehistoric dentistry is far older than 14,000 years as...

Brain-Computer Interfaces (BCI): Towards Humans’ Merger with AI 

The ongoing clinical trials of Brain-Computer Interfaces (BCIs) such...

Tumour Treating Fields (TTFields) approved for Pancreatic cancer

Cancer cells have electrically charged parts hence are influenced...

Newsletter

Don't miss

20C-US: New Coronavirus Variant in the USA

Researchers at Southern Illinois University have reported a new variant of SARS...

NeoCoV: The First Case of a MERS-CoV Related Virus using ACE2

NeoCoV, a coronavirus strain related to MERS-CoV found in...

Gravity Waves Above the Skies of Antarctica

The origins of the mysterious ripples called gravity waves...

Anxiety Relief Through Probiotic and Non-Probiotic Diet Adjustments

A systematic review provides comprehensive evidence that regulating microbiota...

Skin-attachable Loudspeakers and Microphones

A wearable electronic device has been discovered which can...
SCIEU Team
SCIEU Teamhttps://www.scientificeuropean.co.uk
Scientific European® | SCIEU.com | Significant advances in science. Impact on humankind. Inspiring minds.

Meteor Produces Daytime Bolide and Sonic Boom Across New England  

A loud sonic boom was heard and a fireball seen around 18:06 UTC Saturday 30 May 2026 across New England in the northeastern region of the United States. The bright fireball (bolide) was...

Carbon-free Ferrocene Analog Synthesised

The synthesis of the first carbon-free inorganic sandwich compound  (an osmium ion sandwiched between two boron rings), is a fundamental advancement in chemistry. This was sought by chemists for...

Outbreak of Bundibugyo Ebolavirus in DR Congo and Uganda

The current orthoebolavirus outbreak in Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC) and Uganda is confirmed to be caused by the species Orthoebolavirus bundibugyoense (Bundibugyo virus),...